Does retirement bring any dangers?
What research says and thoughts inspired by Romania’s great early retirement by Larisa Dina, our Purposeful Group digital health expert
In 1990, only months after the fall of Ceaușescu, Romania created an opportunity for mass early retirement. A new decree allowed men to draw a full pension after 30 years of work, and women after 25. In practice, this resulted in an increase in the number of retirees receiving a full pension from 1.7 million at the end of 1990 to 1.4 million at the end of 1991.[1] The eligibility for early retirement was further extended for workers engaged in very difficult or difficult professions, who were able to retire with a full pension at ages 50 to 55 years for men, and 45 to 50 years for women. However, the definition for what counted as a difficult profession was lax, such that records of qualified workers grew from around 300,000 in 1989 to 3 million by 1992. This sent a wave of people in their late 40s and 50s out of work for good based on economic reasons – as state industries were restructured, early retirement was used as a buffer against mass unemployment.
Whilst I’m not an economist, as a researcher I see this as a rare opportunity. Studies of retirement and health come up against a problem called reverse causation: people in poorer health tend to retire earlier, so it’s hard to tell whether retirement leads to poorer health or if poorer health prompts earlier retirement. In Romania, this would have been an excellent natural experiment to study the impact of early retirement on health and wellbeing. Regardless, to my knowledge, there is no published research on this cohort of people.
However, I find it interesting linking anecdotal experience with research, even if conducted in other settings, to try to make sense of this phenomenon and understand if there are any harms associated with retirement. Growing up, I’ve watched how my grandparents and others in their generation adapted to this newfound freedom. I noticed some found a new sense of purpose. Many acquaintances set up small businesses such as convenience stores, or threw themselves into their communities. For instance, many of my peers were brought up by their grandparents who had taken over childcare as their parents were busy working. But of course, people adapt in different ways. Without the structure, the colleagues and the sense of being useful that work had given them, I’ve also seen people struggling to fill their days, withdrawing from social life and, years later, visibly affected by cognitive decline.
Anecdotes are just that, of course! But years later, it is interesting to notice that the research seems to point in a similar direction.
So what does the research say?
The key seems to be what replaces work, and not necessarily retirement itself. A [2] followed 9249 working adults aged 50-80 across 14 European countries. On its own, retiring (yes/no) made no difference to quality of life. However, what did make a difference was what happened to people’s close relationships. Retirees whose close networks grew ended up with a better quality of life than those who kept working, while those whose networks shrank ended up worse off. This suggests that poorer outcomes in retirement might work through the quality of our relationships, and how they are preserved.
Staying engaged in some form of work also appears protective. A over seven years, and found that health-related quality of life declined in those who stopped working altogether, but remained steady in those who returned to paid work, with the biggest benefit in those aged 65+. Similarly, [4] had fewer major diseases and functional limitations than those who retired fully.
Purpose also matters. As we saw in a previous newsletter, adults over 50 with the lowest sense of purpose had more than double the mortality risk [5] of those with the highest.
What could explain these associations?
Work can provide a lot of benefits too: a reason to get up in the morning, daily movement, problems to solve, colleagues, and the feeling of being useful. A traditional retirement removes all of these at once. Researchers draw on role theory to explain the pattern: we do best when we replace the role of “worker” with other meaningful roles, whether that’s starting a small business or being a more present grandparent – I find this interesting in light of the anecdotes I shared at the start.
These studies are observational, so they show associations rather than cause and effect. People who start businesses or are involved in raising grandchildren may already be healthier and better connected, and retirement itself can also bring benefits. For instance, French utility workers reported a substantial reduction in mental and physical fatigue and depressive symptoms [6] after retiring, especially in cases where they had chronic diseases.
Some ideas to take away
- It may be a good idea to consider a phased exit, such as reduced hours, or taking on a consultancy role that is more flexible yet allows you to draw on some of the benefits work provides.
- Try to invest in your close relationships deliberately, and make a plan to replace the social contact work provided, or maintain the close relationships you already have.
- Try to find a role that makes you feel useful and encourages learning. It doesn’t have to be any type of formal learning, but providing mentorship or volunteering can be rewarding activities.
If any of the themes discussed in this article strike a chord with you, your Financial Planner can act as a neutral sounding board. They have a wealth of experience leading clients through this transition and you are not alone!
[1] Romania’s Pension System: From Crisis to Reform, (Georges de Menil and Eytan Sheshinski)
[2] Impact of Retirement on Quality of Life: Role of Changes in Social Network Involvement (Settles & Brockman)
[3] Does work after retirement affect health-related quality of life: Evidence from a propensity score matching study in China (Wang, Tian & Fan)
[4] Bridge Employment and Retirees’ Health: A Longitudinal Investigation (Zhan, Wang, Liu & Shultz)
[5] Association Between Life Purpose and Mortality Among US Adults Older Than 50 Years, (Alimujiang, Wiensch, Boss et al)
[6] Effect of retirement on major chronic conditions and fatigue: French GAZEL occupational cohort study (Westerlund, Vahtera, Ferrie et al)
Author: PFM Associates